• Home   /  
  • Archive by category "1"

Norman Golb Festschrift Essays


Investigation Reveals Additional Questionable Identity With Connections to Broyde’s Scholarship

by Steven I. Weiss

A new investigation by The Jewish Channel suggests a deception related to Rabbi Michael Broyde’s academic work that academic ethics experts say would represent a much greater breach of academic ethics than the revelations from a previous investigation published by The Jewish Channel on April 12.

The Jewish Channel has previously revealed that Rabbi Michael Broyde — a prominent rabbi who was reportedly on the shortlist to be chief rabbi of England and is a law professor at U.S. News & World Report’s 23rd-ranked law school at Emory University — created a fake professional identity, Rabbi Hershel Goldwasser, that Broyde used over the course of nearly 20 years. The Goldwasser character joined a rival rabbinic group and gained access to its members-only communications, to argue with other members of that group under the fake identity, to submit letters to scholarly journals that in some cases touted his own work, and engage in other scholarly deceptions.

But a second identity uncovered by The Jewish Channel might have gone farther down the road of academic misconduct than did the Goldwasser character. The second identity, claiming to be an 80-something Ivy League graduate and Talmud scholar in 2010, alleged he’d had conversations with now long-dead sages in the late 1940s or early 1950s. The alleged conversations were used to produce a manufactured history of statements from long-dead scholars that buttressed an argument that Broyde had made in a highly-touted article published in a peer-reviewed scholarly journal. Broyde, in a later publication, subsequently quoted this second identity’s alleged findings as further proof of his original argument.

The consequences for Broyde in creating the Goldwasser character have been greater in his role as rabbi than in his role as a law professor. Broyde has already taken an “indefinite leave of absence” from his position as a judge on the largest rabbinical court in the United States, as well as from his role as a member in the rabbinic professional association with which it is affiliated. The president of that rabbinical group, the Rabbinical Council of America, has called Broyde’s conduct “extremely disturbing.”

But whereas numerous rabbis have explained to The Jewish Channel that the requirements of a rabbinical court judge include having a reputation for unquestioned integrity and honesty, several academic ethics experts have explained that the standards for university professors are different. Broyde’s conduct revealed in The Jewish Channel’s previous reporting thus far is less clear as a violation of academic standards for professors, these experts say.

However, if Broyde created this second identity and alleged historical evidence, that would “clearly be false scholarship” and “clearly require disciplinary review,” according to Professor Celia Fisher of Fordham University, where she is director of the Center for Ethics Education.

Broyde’s conduct as Hershel Goldwasser could be “defensible” if it was used “to stimulate discussion or even controversy,” said the director of the Center for Academic Integrity at Clemson University, Professor Teddi Fishman, but “Making up a supposedly real person to prop up one’s own positions does just the opposite and undermines scholarly integrity.”

Broyde did not reply to multiples e-mails or to multiple voicemails at both his office and mobile phone numbers requesting comment for this story.

Another Character

This second identity involves an 83-page* article by Broyde published as a special supplement of the scholarly journal Tradition in the fall of 2009. A prefatory note to special supplement expresses thanks from the editors of Tradition to two entities, one of which is Broyde’s employer, the Center for the Study of Law and Religion at Emory University, where Broyde is a senior fellow. The two entities “funded this special supplement, thereby enabling Tradition to publish a worthy article that we would not otherwise have been able to print because of considerations of space,” the editors write.

Broyde’s article generated significant controversy within the Orthodox rabbinate and in Jewish scholarly circles for its detailed historical argument suggesting that the dominant view of past rabbinic sages was that married women might not need to cover their hair in public in order to conform to Orthodox Jewish law.

Tradition received multiple letters in response to the article, both supporting and opposing Broyde’s argument. Two of the letters supporting Broyde’s argument aroused editors’ suspicions about their authenticity.

Someone claiming to be David Tzvi Keter wrote one of those letters to Tradition from a Gmail account, establishing a biography in which he claimed he had “moved to Israel in 1949 after graduating from Columbia,” and that he then went on to learn at one of the most prestigious yeshivas in the world at the time, Jerusalem’s Etz Chaim yeshiva, under a major sage of the time, Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer.

The Keter character then goes on to provide a history in which he gathered the oral testimony of several prominent sages of the mid-20th-century on the topic of women’s hair covering. His letter provides their comments 60 years later to add them to the historical record Broyde had been analyzing in the Tradition article.

After Tradition declined to publish the letter, Broyde succeeded in getting the letter published on the Orthodox Jewish scholarship website Hirhurim. Broyde then wrote a follow-up to his Tradition article at Hirhurim, in which he responded to critics and cited the Keter letter as one of three “additional sources that support my position which have come to light since my article came out.”

Finding David Keter

The Jewish Channel has been unable to find any evidence of David Keter’s existence.

Columbia University has no records of a student named David Keter in the 1940s, nor does it have a record for any student having an English version of that name, David Crown, in that era.

The Association of Americans & Canadians in Israel, founded in 1951, as “the primary support organization for immigrants to Israel from North America,” has no record of David Keter in its database. According to a director of the organization, Josie Arbel, “in the early years [membership] was very inexpensive & automatic,” and “all olim [immigrants] arrival info from the Jewish Agency went into our database.” However, it’s possible that someone from 1949 never made contact with the organization, despite the relatively few such immigrants who were in Israel at the time of the organization’s founding.

All but one of the four men named David Keter listed in Israeli phone directories going back to 2003 told The Jewish Channel that they were born in Israel. The family of the David Keter who could not be reached told The Jewish Channel that he died more than 8 years ago, and was also born in Israel.

The only public record The Jewish Channel could find of a David Keter who was not born in Israel was a 1961 Hebrew newspaper article about a lawyer and yoga aficionado who had just emigrated to the country from the United States. The article said that the David Keter who was a subject of their article had changed his name from Isaac Dowd. Columbia University has no records of an Isaac Dowd attending Columbia University in the 1940s, either.

Brandeis University Professor Jonathan Sarna told The Jewish Channel that new immigrants to Israel were frequently featured in the English-language Jerusalem newspaper of the time, The Palestine Post. A search of the online archive for the newspaper produced no mentions of anyone with the last name of Keter.

The Jewish Channel was unsuccessful in trying to get government sources to determine whether David Keter ever received a national identity card, which Israeli law requires every resident of Israel over the age of 16 to carry at all times. Without more identifying information about Keter, the sources said, a search could not be completed.

No One Home

The Keter character provided a fake home address to Tradition editors when they sought to engage him in follow-up correspondence to his original letter.

After Tradition editors initially became suspicious of the Keter letter, they reached out to Keter on January 11, 2010, asking for an address and phone number to contact him. The Keter character wrote back eight days later, apologizing for the delay in response, which he said was because “I had what they tell me is a mini-stroke and I am only now able to read email at all.”

Keter responded with an address and phone number, but Tradition’s editor, Professor Shalom Carmy of Yeshiva University, did not recall doing anything with this information.

The Jewish Channel investigated Keter’s phone number and mailing address in 2013.

The phone number Keter provided to Tradition in 2010 today leads to a message that it is a non-working phone number. The Jewish Channel has been unable to obtain records for the phone number going back to 2010 to determine who, if anyone, once held that number.

Regarding Keter’s alleged address, while the Keter character’s letter claimed to have lived in Jerusalem in the mid-20th-century, he responded to Tradition’s 2010 e-mail inquiry by saying “I live in Maalot Tarshisha now, all the way up north, in 16 Shlomo Hamelech.”

That address the Keter character provided to Tradition consists of two lots. According to property records obtained by The Jewish Channel, the current owners of the two lots have owned those properties since 2002 and 2007. Owners of both properties told The Jewish Channel that they have resided there since their purchases and have never met anyone named David Keter, nor any man living in the area who was Orthodox or born in the United States. A next-door neighbor who told The Jewish Channel she has lived in her home since 1996 said that for as long as she has lived in her home, no one named David Keter, nor anyone born in the United States or who is an Orthodox Jew has lived nearby.

The small town of Maalot Tarshisha, population 20,000, consists mostly of secular Jewish Russian immigrants, with an additional 20% of the population being Arab. The head of the local religious committee for the time period Keter claimed to have lived there, Michael Hazan, told The Jewish Channel that he’d never heard of a David Keter.

Connections With Broyde

Unlike the Hershel Goldwasser character revealed by The Jewish Channel in an earlier investigation, the David Keter character does not claim to know Broyde — but Broyde did claim to have spoken to Keter.

In the months after Tradition chose not to run the Keter letter in January 2010, various outlets were publishing responses to Broyde’s controversial article.

In September 2010, the Jerusalem-based Rabbi Yehuda Herzl Henkin sent a response to the proprietor of the Orthodox Jewish scholarship website Hirhurim, Gil Student, that was critical of Broyde’s article, declaring in part that “Rabbi Broyde’s core position…is untenable.” Henkin told Student that he had originally sent the letter to Tradition, and that the journal had not published it.

Student forwarded Henkin’s letter to Broyde before publishing, and Broyde replied “I have no problem with this — just make sure he knows that Tradition will certainly not publish it if you do.” Broyde then brought up the Keter letter, asking “Can I send you in a more favorable letter to the editor that Tradition declined to publish? Can you publish that also under some section of letters tradition [sic] did not publish?”

Upon Student’s assent, Broyde then forwarded the Keter letter to Student, explaining that he had obtained it when the editor of Tradition “sent it to me as an FYI.” Broyde then requested, “Please do publish it.” The Tradition editor, Carmy, told The Jewish Channel that he has no record of sending Broyde the letter from Keter, but that he regularly deletes old e-mails and that “I had no reason to keep it from Broyde.”

Student wrote to Keter’s e-mail address asking for permission to publish the letter, and Keter replied less than two hours later, writing “That is fine with me. It is an incident that is more than 50 years old now.”

In the days after The Jewish Channel’s investigation of Broyde was published on April 12th of this year, Student specifically asked Broyde whether Keter was a real person. Broyde responded that Keter is real, as Broyde had personally spoken to him by phone.

In a later conversation, Broyde told Student that Keter had given Broyde access to Keter’s Gmail account, and that Broyde had edited Keter’s original letter before sending it to Tradition.

Gmail accounts, unlike the Hotmail account used by the Goldwasser character, do not include the Internet Protocol, or IP, addresses of those sending messages from Gmail in their metadata.

How Could Keter Exist?

Student published Keter’s letter on Hirhurim in September 2010, and soon thereafter heard from readers, including editors at Tradition, about the factual concerns regarding Keter’s letter.

The overall biography for Keter is extraordinary. He claims to have graduated Columbia University in the 1940s, an era when being an Orthodox Jew in an Ivy League school was extremely rare, according to Brandeis University Professor Jonathan Sarna. “You still had quotas in the 1940s,” Sarna said in a phone interview, where rules existed such that “Jews are not more than 10 percent [of those enrolled as students], usually less, at top universities, and of those Jews, the vast majority tended to be non-Orthodox, since it was especially difficult to be an Orthodox Jew on most Ivy League campuses.”

Keter then claims to have moved to Israel in 1949, just after Israel’s war of independence and before many of the basic government services — including immigrant absorption — had been established in the Jewish State. “Back in 1949, aliyah [immigration to Israel] from America was highly unusual,” Sarna wrote in an e-mail to The Jewish Channel, adding “Orthodox American college students were no exception to that rule.” Sarna noted that “many of whose who did make aliyah returned after a few years,” because “Israel was a third-world country in 1949, and Americans did not find living there easy.” Sarna concluded that, “I am not aware of any precise figures concerning American Orthodox olim with college educations, but I suspect that you could count their numbers on your fingers and toes.”

Once in Israel, Keter claims to have studied at one of the most prestigious yeshivas of its era, which would usually require years of high-level Talmud study instead of schooling on secular subjects at an Ivy League University. While Meltzer’s yeshiva “certainly had taken American students” in the first half of the twentieth century, “they would tend to be people who went to Yeshiva Etz Chaim in America or another yeshiva, and then gone off,” instead of having gone to university.

Asked about the possibility of an Orthodox Jew doing all of these things — attending Columbia University in the 1940s or earlier, then moving to Israel in 1949, and studying in Meltzer’s yeshiva — Sarna answered in the phone interview, “Whoa, that’s unusual.” Sarna added, “I’m not going to say the facts are impossible,” but “I would ask a lot of questions.”

That such an exceptional figure would then never be heard from in the field of Jewish scholarship, until he wrote a single letter 60 years later, struck many scholars contacted by The Jewish Channel as extremely odd.

Presenting a New Narrative

The story Keter relayed also struck editors at Tradition as odd. The premise of the Keter letter as a response to Broyde’s article is that, while learning at the exclusive Jerusalem yeshiva under the sage Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer, “I was engaged to a woman who would not cover her hair and I spoke to the Rav Meltzer about this matter at some length.”

Keter relates that Meltzer was initially dismissive of Keter’s inquiry: “He told me that it was better not to marry someone who would not cover her hair.” But Keter was able to get the sage to refer the question elsewhere by citing the power of love: “After I told him that I really loved this woman and wanted to marry, he graciously gave me permission to speak to three of his students, Rabbi Yehuda Gershuni, Rabbi Elazar Shach and Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Auerbach.”

“So off I went” to meet those rabbis, Keter declares.

Keter’s letter then cites responses from Gershuni and Auerbach that are broadly consistent with what the historical record reveals.

Where Keter’s letter goes into completely new territory, and the portion which Broyde cited in a later publication, is in Keter’s testimony about Shach. “[I]t was Rav Shach who startled me with his halachic [rabbinic legal] view,” Keter wrote. After discussing the issue in detail, “Rav Shach told me that it was better to be strict on this matter, but one who was makil [lenient], yesh al ma lismoch [he has what to rely upon].”

It is this paragraph about Shach’s attitudes that Broyde cites in an article on Hirhurim, declaring that “a recollection by David Keter of a conversation he had with Rav Shach,” is one of three “additional sources that support my position which have come to light since my article came out.”

A Story That Couldn’t Have Happened

As improbable as scholars find the overall narrative of the man named David Tzvi Keter, the letter itself contains a false detail that suggests Keter’s story is untrue.

Scholars suggest it was extremely unusual that an Orthodox Jew would have attended Columbia University in the 1940s, and indeed Columbia University has no records of this man. They also find it extremely unlikely that a man who was so well-versed in secular learning that he could attend Columbia could also develop the Talmudic skills to be immediately accepted into an exclusive yeshiva just after graduating college.

But the stories about the new history provided by Keter raised questions, as well. Scholars questioned whether the chronology suggested by the letter was consistent with recorded history, and whether the historical statements Keter provided were reflective of the long-dead rabbis’ actual attitudes — especially those regarding Shach.

And indeed, in one detail in the letter, Keter includes a historical inaccuracy that reveals his narrative could not have happened as Keter claims it did. The author says he “moved to Israel in 1949″ before his rabbinic adventure began. All four rabbis Keter claims to have spoken to were in Israel then, but Gershuni left Israel for the United States shortly thereafter, in 1950, according to a 2005 memorial book edited by Itamar Warhaftig, Afikei Yehuda.

However, the conversation with Shach that Keter relates could not have happened until 1952, two years after Gershuni left Israel.

Keter tells of Shach saying that “his wife had not covered her hair in Europe or while he was learning at Etz Chaim,” but that things changed for Shach when he became an instructor at a different yeshiva. “Now that he was at Ponevitch she certainly did cover her hair,” Keter claims Shach said. Shach only started teaching at the Ponevitch yeshiva in 1952, according to a 1989 biography of the rabbi by Moshe Horovitz, HaRav Shach Shehamaphteach Beyado.

Gone

In October 2010, Student, the Hirhurim editor, gathered various of the factual objections to Keter’s letter and asked Keter about them in an e-mail. Student also mentioned in the e-mail a result of Student’s correspondence with editors of Tradition after he published the letter, that a nephew of a Tradition editor then studying in Israel wanted to meet Keter.

Student, trying not to appear accusatory, concluded, “I apologize if these request [sic] offends you. You have already been generous with sharing your experience and any further information you give is at your discretion.”

Keter never replied.

[Correction, April 30: This story originally claimed Broyde's article in Tradition's supplement was 179 pages long. While the last page is numbered 179, the first page of the supplement is numbered 97. The Jewish Channel regrets the error.]

April 24, 2013 | Read more Newsdesk posts.91 Comments »

Comments

Bibliography of Khazar Studies, 1901-Present
Compiled by Kevin Alan Brook

Section 1: Introductory Works


GENERAL WORKS ABOUT THE KHAZARS

In Bulgarian:


        Zhivkov, Boris. Khazaria prez IX i X vek. Sofia, Bulgaria: IK Gutenberg, 2010. Translated into English under the title Khazaria in the 9th and 10th Centuries, translated by Daria Manova, published in Leiden, Netherlands by Brill Academic Publishers in 2015.

In Chinese:
        Gui, Baoli. Kesa Tujue. Lanzhou Shi, China: Lanzhou da xue chu ban she, 2013.

In English:
        Ajzenstadt, Michael. "An Incredible Journey to the Lost Empire of the Khazars." The Jerusalem Post (March 17, 1997): 5. An article about the travels of Ehud Ya'ari's documentary team.
        Barthold, Vasilii Vladimirovich, and Golden, Peter Benjamin. "Khazar." In The Encyclopedia of Islam, vol. 4, pp. 1172-1181. Leiden and London, 1978.
        Brook, Kevin Alan. The Jews of Khazaria (1st edition). Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson, 1999. Translated into Turkish under the title Bir Türk İmparatorluğu: Hazar Yahudileri, translated by İsmail Tulçali, published in Istanbul by Nokta Kitap in 2005. 2nd edition published in English in Lanham, MD by Rowman and Littlefield in 2006.
        Brook, Kevin Alan. "A Brief History of the Khazars." In The Kuzari: In Defense of the Despised Faith, Korobkin edition, pp. xxv-xxxi. Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson, 1998. Revised version of the essay on pp. 31-40 in 2nd edition of The Kuzari, published in Jerusalem, Israel and Nanuet, NY by Feldheim Publishers in 2009.
        Christian, David Gilbert. A History of Russia, Central Asia and Mongolia. Vol. 1: Inner Eurasia from Prehistory to the Mongol Empire. Oxford, UK: Blackwell, 1998. See especially pages 282-303 of chapter 11.
        Dunlop, Douglas Morton. "Aspects of the Khazar Problem." Transactions of the Glasgow University Oriental Society 12 (1951): 33-44.
        Dunlop, Douglas Morton. The History of the Jewish Khazars. New York: Schocken, 1967 and Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1954. Translated into Persian under the title [The History of Khazaria from Its Inception to Its Demise] and published in Tehran in 2003 by Qoqnus Publishing. Translated into Turkish under the title "Hazar yahudi tarihi" and published in Istanbul in 2008 by Selenge yayınları. Translated into Russian under the title "Istoriya khazar-iudeev: religiya vysshikh klanov" and published in Moscow in 2016 by Tsentrpoligraf.
        Dunlop, Douglas Morton. "The Khazars." In The Dark Ages: Jews in Christian Europe, 711-1096, ed. Cecil Roth and I. H. Levine, pp. 325-356. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 1966. World History of the Jewish People, second series, vol. 2.
        Dunlop, Douglas Morton. "Khazars." In Encyclopedia Judaica, vol. 10, pp. 945-954. Jerusalem: Keter, 1971-1972.
        Fedortchouk, Artem. "Khazars." In A Dictionary of Jewish-Christian Relations, ed. Edward Kessler and Neil Wenborn, p. 252. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, 2005.
        Franklin, Simon, and Shepard, Jonathan. The Emergence of Rus 750-1200. London: Longman, 1996.
        Frenkel, Anna. "The Jewish Empire in the Land of Future Russia." Australian Journal of Jewish Studies 9:1-2 (1995): 142-170.
        Golb, Norman, and Pritsak, Omeljan. Khazarian Hebrew Documents of the Tenth Century. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1982. Translated into Russian under the title Khazarsko-yevreiskie dokumenty X veka, published by Gesharim of Moscow and Jerusalem in 1997. The Russian edition includes a new essay by Vladimir Iakovlevich Petrukhin.
        Golden, Peter Benjamin. Khazar Studies: An Historico-Philological Inquiry into the Origins of the Khazars. Vol. 1. Budapest: Akadémiai Kiadó, 1980. Translated into Turkish in 2006 under the title Hazar Çalışmaları, translated by E. Ç. Mizrak, published in Istanbul by Selenge yayınları.
        Golden, Peter Benjamin. "Khazars." In Encyclopedia of Asian History, ed. Ainslie T. Embree, vol. 2, pp. 295-296. New York: Scribner, 1988.
        Golden, Peter Benjamin. "The Khazars of Record." The World and I (November 1988): 368-377.
        Golden, Peter Benjamin. "The Khazars." In The Cambridge History of Early Inner Asia, ed. Denis Sinor, pp. 263-270. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, 1990.
        Golden, Peter Benjamin. "Khazars." In Turkish-Jewish Encounters: Studies on Turkish-Jewish Relations through the Ages, ed. Mehmet Tütüncü, pp. 29-49. Haarlem, Netherlands: SOTA, 2001.
        Golden, Peter Benjamin. "Some Notes on the Comitatus in Medieval Eurasia with Special Reference to the Khazars." Russian History/Histoire russe 28:1-4 (2001): 153-170. Festschrift in Honor of Thomas S. Noonan, Vol. 1, eds. Roman K. Kovalev and Heidi M. Sherman.
        Golden, Peter Benjamin. "Khazar Turkic Ghulâms in Caliphal Service." Journal Asiatique 292:1-2 (2004): 279-309. About ghulâms of Khazar origin who were in service to the Abbasid Caliphate.
        Golden, Peter Benjamin. "Khazaria." In The YIVO Encyclopedia of Jews in Eastern Europe, vol. 1, eds. Gershom David Hundert, et al., pp. 888-890. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2008.
        Gottesman, Brian Michael. "The Empire of the Khazars." In World History Encyclopedia, Era 4: Expanding Regional Civilizations, 300-1000, ed. Wilfred J. Bisson, et al. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, 2011.
        Gumilev, Lev Nikolaevich. "Khazaria and Caspian: (Landscape and Ethnos, Part I)." Soviet Geography 5:6 (New York, 1964): 54-68.
        Gumilev, Lev Nikolaevich. "Khazaria and Terek: (Landscape and Ethnos, Part II)." Soviet Geography 7:2 (New York, 1966): 14-26.
        Gumilev, Lev Nikolaevich. "Khazaria and Caspian." The Geographical Review 60:3 (New York, 1970): 367-377.
        Jacobs, Louis. "Khazars." In Oxford Concise Companion to the Jewish Religion, p. 124. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press, 1999.
        Klyashtorny, Sergei Grigorievich. "The Asian Aspect of the Early Khazar History." In Florilegia Altaistica: Studies in Honour of Denis Sinor on the Occasion of his 90th Birthday, eds. Elena Vladimirovna Boikova and Giovanni Stary, pp. 61-67. Wiesbaden, Germany: Harrassowitz Verlag, 2006.
        Koestler, Arthur. The Thirteenth Tribe: The Khazar Empire and Its Heritage. London: Hutchinson and Co., 1976 and New York: Random House, 1976. Translated into French in 1976, into German in 1977/1991, into Turkish in 1977/1984, into Greek in 1978, into Italian in 1980, into Spanish in 1980, into Persian in 1982/1983, into Romanian in 1987 and 2002, into Hungarian in 1990, into Japanese in 1990, into Swedish in 1992, into Serbo-Croatian in 1997 and 2000, into Russian in 1998 and 2001, into Hebrew in 1999, into Portuguese in 2005, and into Bulgarian in 2006.
        Kovalev, Roman K. "Khazars." In Encyclopedia of Russian History, vol. 2, eds. James R. Millar, et al., pp. 739-740. New York: Macmillan Reference USA, 2004.
        Kramers, J. M. (A lecture on the Khazars.) Analecta Orientalia 1 (Leiden, 1954): 130-143.
        Lasker, Daniel J. "Khazars." In The Encyclopedia of Judaism, ed. Geoffrey Wigoder, p. 414. New York: Macmillan, 1989.
        Lvov, Arkady. "Shades of Forgotten Ancestors." Midstream 29:2 (February 1983): 49-54.
        Meerts, Paul. "Assessing Khazaria."International Institute for Asian Studies (IIAS) Newsletter No. 34 (July 2004): 15.
        Noonan, Thomas Schaub. "Nomads and Sedentarists in a Multi-Ethnic Empire: The Role of the Khazars in the Khazar Khaganate." Archivum Eurasiae Medii Aevi 15 (2006/2007): 107-?.
        Obolensky, Dimitry. "The Crimea and the North before 1204." Archion Pontou 35 (1979): 123-133.
        Petrukhin, Vladimir Iakovlevich. "The Decline and Legacy of Khazaria." In Europe around the Year 1000, ed. Przemysław Urbańczyk, pp. 109-122. Warsaw: DiG, 2001.
        Pletnyova, Svetlana Aleksandrovna. "The Khazars." In Peoples That Vanished, ed. Pavel Ivanovich Puchkov, trans. Ye. Voronov, pp. 49-60. Moscow: Nauka, 1989.
        Pritsak, Omeljan. "Khazars." In Dictionary of the Middle Ages, vol. 7, pp. 240-242. New York: Scribner, 1986.
        Pritsak, Omeljan. "Khazaria." In The Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium, ed. Alexander P. Kazhdan, vol. 2, pp. 1126-1127. New York: Oxford University Press, 1991.
        Pritsak, Omeljan. "Khazars." In The Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium, ed. Alexander P. Kazhdan, vol. 2, p. 1127. New York: Oxford University Press, 1991.
        Richard, Jean. "Khazars." In Encyclopedia of the Middle Ages, ed. André Vauchez, vol. 1, p. 801. Chicago and London: Fitzroy Dearborn, 2000.
        Rosenthal, Herman. "Chazars." In The Jewish Encyclopedia, vol. 4, pp. 1-7. New York: Funk and Wagnalls, 1901-1906 and New York: Ktav, 1964.
        Shapira, Dan D. Y. "Some Notes on Jews and Turks." Karadeniz Araştırmaları No. 16 (Winter 2008): 25-38.
        Soteri, Nicholas. "Khazaria: A Forgotten Jewish Empire."History Today 45:4 (April 1995): 10-12.
        Starr, Joshua. "Khazars." In Universal Jewish Encyclopedia, ed. Isaac Landman, vol. 6, pp. 375-378. New York, 1948.
        Weinryb, Bernard Dov. "Solving the Khazar Problem. A Study in Soviet Historiography." Judaism 13:4 (Fall 1964): 431-443.
        Ya'ari, Ehud. "Skeletons in the Closet." The Jerusalem Report 6:9 (Sept. 7, 1995): 26-30. Ya'ari, an Israeli journalist, describes his television film crew's expedition to Khazaria during the mid-1990s and presents a fairly good summary of Khazarian history.
        Ya'ari, Ehud. "Archaeological Finds Add Weight to Claim that Khazars Converted to Judaism." The Jerusalem Report 10:4 (June 21, 1999): 8. Discusses the Khazar studies conference that was held in Jerusalem during May 24-28, 1999.
        Yücel, Muallâ Uydu. "The Khazar Empire." In The Turks, vol. 1, eds. Hasan Celâl Güzel, C. Cem Oguz, and Osman Karatay, pp. 491-508. Ankara, Turkey: Yeni Türkiye, 2002.
        Zhukovsky, Arkadii. "Khazars." In Encyclopedia of Ukraine, ed. Volodymyr Kubijovyc, vol. 2, pp. 462-463. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1988.
        (Author?) "Old Manuscripts Reveal a Lost Jewish Kingdom."The New York Times (November 17, 1912).

In French:
        Baschmakoff, Alexandre. "Une solution nouvelle du problème des Khazares. Leur origine et la raison de leur judaïsation." Mercure de France 229 (1931): 39-73.
        Gourand, Jean-Louis. "Quelques propos cavaliers sur les Khazars." In L'Empire khazar VIIe-XIe siècle: L'enigme d'un peuple cavalier, eds. Jacques Piatigorsky and Jacques Sapir, pp. 117-142. Paris: Autrement, 2005.
        Halter, Marek. "Prologue. Sur les traces des Khazars." In L'Empire khazar VIIe-XIe siècle: L'enigme d'un peuple cavalier, eds. Jacques Piatigorsky and Jacques Sapir, pp. 5-13. Paris: Autrement, 2005.
        Jean-Baptiste, Patrick. "Une nouvelle histoire des Khazars: Le royaume juif de la Volga."Sciences et Avenir No. 650 (April 2001): 123-?.
        Sorlin, Irène. "Le problème des Khazares et les historiens soviétiques dans les vingt dernières années." Travaux et Mémoires du Centre de recherche d'histoire et civilisation byzantine 3:51 (1968): 423-455.
        Szyszman, Simon. "Les Khazars. Problèmes et controverses." Revue de l'histoire des religious 152:2 (Paris: October-December 1957): 174-221.
        Szyszman, Simon. "Découverte de la Khazarie." Annales: économies, sociétés, civilisations 25:3 (Paris, 1970): 818-821.
        Terechtchenko, Alexei. "Que sait-on des Khazars ou état des lieux historique d'un peuple oublié." In L'Empire khazar VIIe-XIe siècle: L'enigme d'un peuple cavalier, eds. Jacques Piatigorsky and Jacques Sapir, pp. 35-78. Paris: Autrement, 2005.
        Weill, Nicolas. "L'histoire retrouvée des Khazars."Le Monde (July 9, 1999): 12. Discusses the Khazar studies conference that was held in Jerusalem during May 24-28, 1999, and various scholarship in the Khazar field.

In German:
        Aufgebauer, Peter. "Chasaren." In Neues Lexikon des Judentums, ed. Julius H. Schoeps, p. 92. München, Germany: Bertelsmann-Lexikon-Verlag, 1992.
        Bart'old, Vasilii Vladimirovich. "al-Khazar." In Enzyklopädie des Islam: Geographisches, ethnographisches und biographisches Wörterbuch der muhammedanischen Völker, vol. 2, eds. Martijn Theodoor Houtsma, et al., pp. 1003-1005. Leiden: Brill, 1927.
        Baschmakoff, Alexandre. "Neues über die Chazaren." Litterae Orientales: orientalistischer Literaturbericht No. 58 (Leipzig, Germany, April 1934): 4-6.
        Brutzkus, Julius Davidovich. "Chasaren." In Encyclopaedia Judaica: Das Judentum in Geschichte und Gegenwart, vol. 5, col. 337-350. Berlin: Eschkol, 1930.
        Kmoskó, Mihály. "Araber und Chasaren." Kõrösi Csoma-Archivum 1:4 (Budapest, 1924): 280-292, 1:5 (Budapest, 1925): 356-368.
        Kutschera, Hugo von. Die Chasaren: historische Studie. Vienna: A. Holzhausen, 1910.
        Landau, Maximilian. Beiträge zum Chazarenproblem. Breslau: Stefan Munz Jüdischer Buchverlag, 1938.
        Ludwig, Dieter. "Chazaren." In Lexikon des Mittelalters, vol. 2, pp. 1783-1788. München, Germany: Artemis, 1983.
        Meisl, Josef. "Chazaren." In Jüdisches Lexikon, vol. 1, pp. 1346-1350. Berlin: Jüdischer Verlag, 1927.
        Posselt, Alfred H. Geschichte des chazarisch-jüdischen Staates. Vienna: Vereines zur Förderung und Pflege des Reformjudentums, 1982.
        Rolle, R. "Chazaren." In Reallexikon der Germanischen Altertumskunde, ed. Heinrich Beck, vol. 4, pp. 413-422. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, 1981.
        Roth, Andreas. Chasaren. Das vergessene Großreich der Juden. Neu Isenburg, Germany: Melzer Verlag, 2006.
        Zeki Validi Togan, Ahmed. "Völkerschaften des Chazarenreiches im neunten Jahrhundert." Kõrösi Csoma-Archivum 3:1 (Budapest, 1940).

In Hebrew:
        Landau, Maximilian. [The Present State of the Khazar Problem]. Zion 8 (Jerusalem, 1942-1943): 94-106.
        Lior, Joshua. Ha-Kuzarim: le-or ha-historiografyah ha-Sovyetit. Ramat-Gan, Israel: Universitat Bar-Ilan, 1973.
        Poliak, Abraham Nahum. Kazariyah: Toldot mamlaxa yehudit be'europa. Tel Aviv, Israel: Mosad Bialik, 1942 (1st edition), 1944 (2nd edition), 1951 (3rd edition). Translated into Polish under the title Chazaria: Dzieje Królestwa Żydowskiego w Europie, published in Przemyśl, Poland by Południowo - Wschodni Instytut Naukowy in 2015.
        Simonsohn, Shlomo. "Ha-Khuzarim, mi haiu? ha'im haiu Yehudim? l'an ne'elmu? ma anu yod'im alehem?" Et-mol 23 (135) (1997): 3-5. Summary of Koestler's research on the Khazars' kingdom, their Judaism, and their diaspora.
        Uziel, Meir. "Ha-imperiya ha-yehudit ha-nishkakhat: Kazariya hi akhat ha-khidot ha-gdolot shel ha-historiya."Ma'ariv (May 16, 2002).
        Ya'ari, Ehud. "Ha-masa ha-mufla be-ikvot ha-Kuzarim." Ma'ariv - Sofshavua supplement (March 14, 1997): 32-36.
        Zohori, Menahem. Ha-Kuzarim, hitgayrutam ve-korotehem: ba-sifrut ha-historiyografyah ha-'Ivrit. Jerusalem, 1976 and Jerusalem: Karmel, 2002. The Khazars' conversion and history as detailed in medieval Jewish sources.

In Hungarian:
        Bartha, Miklós. Kazárföldön. Budapest: Stádium, 1939 and London: Hidfo Barati Kore, 1970. Reprinted in Budapest in 1996.
        Czeglédy, Károly. "Ogurok és türkök Kazáriában." In Magyar õstórténeti tanulmányok, szerk. Antal Bartha, Károly Czeglédy, and András Róna-Tas, pp. 59-63. Budapest: Akadémiai Kiadó, 1977.
        Deutsch, Gábor. "Millecentenáriumi mozaik. Kazár kapcsolat." Új Élet 51 (1996): 16 p.1
        Marmorstein, A. "Új adatok a kazárok történetéhez." Egyetemes philologiai közlöny 38 (1914): 148-152.
        Vékony, Gábor. "A kazár kérdés." Életünk (1992): 919-938.
        Zimonyi, István. "A kazárok szerepe Kelet-Európában." Magyar Tudomány 103 U.F. 41 (1996): 952-957.

In Italian:
        Marturano, Aldo C. Mescekh: Il paese degli ebrei dimenticati. Poggiardo, Italy: Atena, 2004.
        Signorini, Alberto. "Che fine hanno fatto i Cazari di Koestler." Los Muestros: The Sephardic Voice No. 18 (March 1995): 5-10.
        Signorini, Alberto. "Che fine hanno fatto i Cazari di Koestler (2nda parte)." Los Muestros: The Sephardic Voice No. 19 (June 1995).

In Polish:
        Dąbrowski, Krzysztof; Nagrodzka-Majchrzyk, Teresa; and Tryjarski, Edward. Hunowie Europejscy, Protobułgarzy, Chazarowie, Pieczyngowie. Warsaw-Wroclaw-Kraków Zakład Narodowy im. Ossolińskich, 1975.
        Dudek, Jarosław. Chazarowie: Polityka - kultura - religia, VII-XI wiek. Poland: Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN, 2016.
        Swoboda, W. "Chazarowie." In Słownik starożytności słowiańskich: encyklopedyczny zarys kultury slowian od czasow najdawniejszych Pod red. Wladyslawa Kowalenki, Gerarda Labudy i Tadeusza Lehra-Splawinskiego. Vol. 1, pp. 238-239. Wroclaw: Zklad Narodowy im. Ossolinskich, 1961.
        Zajączkowski, Ananiasz. "Ze studiów nad zagadnieniem chazarskim." Prace Komisji Orientalistycznej (Kraków) No. 36. Also printed by Kraków: Nakl. Polskiej Akademii Umiejetnosci, 1947.

In Portuguese:
        Finguerman, Ariel. "Um novo livro a respeito dos judeus khazares."Hebraica (Brazil) (May 2007): 62-64. An article about the Khazars including an interview with Kevin Brook, illustrations, and the sidebar "Quem foram os khazares?".

In Russian:
        Aleksin, Aleksandr Aleksandrovich, and Gumilev, Lev Nikolaevich. "Khazarskaya Atlantida." Aziya i Afrika segodnya (1962) No. 2: 52-53.
        Artamonov, Mikhail Illarionovich. Ocherki drevneishei istorii khazar. Leningrad: Gos. sots-ekon. izd-vo. (Sotsekgiz), 1936. Focuses on the earlier periods of Khazar history.
        Artamonov, Mikhail Illarionovich. Istoriya Xazar. Leningrad: Ermitazha (Hermitage Museum), 1962 and St. Petersburg: Lan', 2001 and St. Petersburg: Peterburgskii gos. universitet. Filologicheskii fakul'tet, 2002. Translated into Turkish under the title Hazar Tarihi: Türkler Yahudiler Ruslar, published in Istanbul by Selenge yayınları in 2004.
        Bart'old, Vasilii Vladimirovich. "Khazary." In Sochineniya, vol. 5. Moscow: Nauka, 1968.
        Belov, Evgenii. "O Xazarax." Russkaya Mysl (Paris, March 21, 1968) No. 2679.
        Charny, Semyon. "600 lyet vmeste i 50 lyet lzhi."Lekhaim 3 (131) (March 2003).
        Fedorov, A. Ia. "Khazariya i Dagestan." Kavkazii etnograficheskii sbornik 5 (1972): 30-31. (Trudy Instituta etnografii, n.s., Tom 99)
        Flyorov, Valerii Sergeevich. "Kollokvium 'Khazary' (Ierusalim, 1999) i 'Kratkaya Yevreyskaya entsiklopediya' o xazarax." Rossiyskaya arkheologiya (2000) No. 3.
        Goldelman, Menashe. "Khazariya." In Kratkaya Yevreyskaya Ensiklopediya, vol. 9, pp. 522-541. Jerusalem, 1999.
        Gumilev, Lev Nikolaevich. "Khazariya i Kaspiy (Landshaft i etnos: I)." Vestnik Leningradskogo Universiteta 1:6 (1964): 83-95.
        Gumilev, Lev Nikolaevich. "Khazariya i Terek (Landshaft i etnos: II)." Vestnik Leningradskogo Universiteta 4:24 (1964): 78-88.
        Gumilev, Lev Nikolaevich. "Sosedi Khazar." Strany i narody Vostoka 7:14 (Moscow, 1965): 127-142.
        Gumilev, Lev Nikolaevich. Otkrytie Xazarii. Istoriko-geograficheskiy etyud. Moscow: Nauka, Glav. red. vostochnoi lit-ry, 1966. Translated into Czech by Ivan Savicky under the title Obieveni zeme Chazaru and published in Prague in 1971 by Miada Fronta. Translated into Turkish by D. Ahsen Batur under the title Hazar Çevresinde Bin Yil and published in 2002 by Selenge yayınları.
        Gumilev, Lev Nikolaevich. "Skazanie o Xazarskoy dani (opit kriticheskogo kommentariya)." Russkaya literatura (1974) No. 3.
        Gumilev, Lev Nikolaevich, and other Russian scholars. Compiled by A. I. Kurkchi. Sochineniya L. N. Gumileva v 15 Tomakh - Vol. 6: Otkrytie Xazarii. Moscow: Di-Dik, 1996.
        Kaganovich, Al'bert. "Pervaya mezhdunarodnaya konferentsiya po problemam izucheniya istorii xazar."Tsentral'naya Aziya i Kavkaz (1999) No. 4(5). Discusses the Khazar studies conference that was held in Jerusalem during May 24-28, 1999.
        Kalinina, Tatyana M. Problemy istorii Khazarii (po dannym vostochnyh istochnikov). Moscow: Russkii fond sodeistviya obrazovaniyu i nauke, 2015. Anthology of decades of Kalinina's scholarly articles about the Khazars.
        Kandel, Feliks (Felix) Solomonovich. Ocherki vremen i sobytii: iz istorii rossiiskikh evreev, do vtoroi poloviny vosemnadtsatogo veka. Jerusalem: Assotsiatsiya "Tarbut", 1988. Essays about the history of eastern European Jews from their beginnings until the second half of the 18th century, including material on the Khazars and the Kievan Letter.
        Khainman, Irma. Yevreiskaya diaspora i Rus'. Jerusalem: Irma Khainman, 1983.
        Klimovitsky, Lev. Khazaria: Gosudarstvo synov Israilia v izgnanii. Yevrei i russkie: tysyacha chetyresta let vmeste. Ramla, Israel: M+, 2003. Presents Hebrew, Russian, and other sources on the Khazars, and claims that Khazars descended from Israelites.
        Klyashtornyi, Sergey Grigorievich and Sultanov, T. I. Gosudarstva i Narody Evraziiskikh Stepei: Drevnost i Srednevekove. St. Petersburg: Peterburgskoye Vostokovedenie, 2000.
        Kolobova, Oleg, Ivanov, Valeriy, and Klyutchnikov, Vladimir. Khazary. Moscow: Lomonosov, 2013. (Kolobova and Ivanov are pseudonymed together as "Oleg Ivik" in this book.)
        Kruglov, Eugene V. "Xazary - istoriya tol'ko nachinaetsya." In Xazary: Vtoroi Mezhdunarodnii kollokvium: tezisy, ed. Vladimir Iakovlevich Petrukhin and Artyom M. Fedorchuk, pp. 61-65? Moscow: Tsentr nauchnyx rabotnikov i prepodavatelei iudaiki v vuzakh "Sefer", Evreiskii universitet v Moskve, and Institut Slavyanovedeniya Rossiiskoy akademii nauk, 2002.
        Magomedov, Murad Gadgievich. Khazary na Kavkaze. Makhachkala, Russia: Dagestanskoye knizhnoye izdatel'stvo, 1994.
        Maniagin, V. G., Pletnyova, Svetlana Aleksandrovna, and Gumilev, Lev Nikolaevich. Khazary, ili Tainstvennyi sled v russkoi istorii. Moscow: Algoritm, 2008.
        Marchenko, V. T. Khazary, Mongoly i Rus': Ocherk istorii Evrazii. Moscow, 1993.
        Naumenko, Valery E. "K voprosu o vremeny i obstoyatel'stvax obrazovaniya Xazarskogo kaganata." Khazarskiy al'manax 2 (Kharkiv, 2004): 52-76.
        Novosel'tsev, Anatolii Petrovich. "Xazariya v sisteme mezhdunarodnix otnosheniy VII-IX vv." Voprosy istorii (1987) No. 2: 20-32.
        Novosel'tsev, Anatolii Petrovich. Khazarskoye gosudarstvo i ego rol' v istorii vostochnoi Yevropy i Kaukaza. Moscow: Nauka, 1990.
        Olshanetzki, I. A. "Koe chto o Xazarskix evreyax." Izvestiya obshchestva isledovaniya i izucheniya Azerbaydzhana (Baku, 1928): 134-140.
        Petrukhin, Vladimir Iakovlevich, and Raevskii, Dmitrii Sergeevich. Ocherki istorii narodov Rossii v drevnosti i rannem srednevekov'e. Moscow: Shkola "Iazyki russkoi kul'tury", 1998. A short history of the peoples of Russia. Chapter 9 (pages 198-225) discuss the Khazars.
        Pletnyova, Svetlana Aleksandrovna. Khazary. Moscow: Nauka, 1986. Previously published in German under the title Die Chasaren: mittelalterliches Reich an Don und Wolga in Leipzig, Germany in 1978. Translated into Japanese in 1996.
        Pletnyova, Svetlana Aleksandrovna. "Xazary i Xazarskiy kaganat." In Xazary: Vtoroi Mezhdunarodnii kollokvium: tezisy, ed. Vladimir Iakovlevich Petrukhin and Artyom M. Fedorchuk, pp. 81-84? Moscow: Tsentr nauchnyx rabotnikov i prepodavatelei iudaiki v vuzakh "Sefer", Evreiskii universitet v Moskve, and Institut Slavyanovedeniya Rossiiskoy akademii nauk, 2002.
        Romashov, Sergei A. "Istoricheskaya Geografiya Xazarskogo Kaganata (V-XIII vv.) (Chasti I i II)" Archivum Eurasiae Medii Aevi 11 (2000-2001): 219-338.
        Romashov, Sergei A. "Istoricheskaya Geografiya Xazarskogo Kaganata (V-XIII vv.) (Chast' III i karty)" Archivum Eurasiae Medii Aevi 12 (2002-2003): 81-222.
        Romashov, Sergei A. "Istoricheskaya Geografiya Xazarskogo Kaganata (V-XIII vv.) (Chast' IV i V)" Archivum Eurasiae Medii Aevi 13 (2004): ?-?.
        Romashov, Sergei A. "Istoricheskaya Geografiya Xazarskogo Kaganata (V-XIII vv.) (Chast' VI i VII)" Archivum Eurasiae Medii Aevi 14 (2005): ?-?.
        Rychka, V. [And Khazars Came to Them]. Rodina No. 4-5 (2002): 48-49. About indications of Khazar settlements in the middle Dnieper valley in Slavic-majority cities and villages.
        Semyonov, Igor' Godovich. Istoriya stran i narodov Zapadnogo Prikaspiya: 1-e tysiacheletie novoi ery. Kazan, Tatarstan, Russia: Tan-Zaria, 1994. Discusses Khazars in Daghestan and along Caspian coast.
        Semyonov, Igor' Godovich. "K voprosu ob istoricheskoy geografii Xazarii." In Materialy vos'moy Ezhegodnoy Mezhdunarodnoy Mezhdistsiplinarnoy konferentsii po iudaike, Chast' 1, ed. K. Yu. Burmistrov, R. M. Kaplanov, and V. V. Mochalova, pp. 179-190. Moscow: Sefer, 2001.
        Stoliar, A. D. and Vilinbakhov, Georgii, eds. Skify, khazary, slaviane, Drevnyaya Rus: Mezhdunarodnaya nauchnaya konferentsiya, posviashchennaya 100-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya professora Mikhaila Illarionovicha Artamonova: Sankt-Peterburg, 9-12 dekabria 1998 g.: tezisy dokladov. St. Petersburg, Russia: Izd-vo Gosudarstvennogo Ermitazha, 1998. Papers from a conference honoring the late Mikhail Artamonov.
        Tortika, Aleksandr Aleksandrovich. Severo-Zapadnaya Khazariya v kontekste istorii Vostochnoy Yevropy (vtoraya polovina VII -- tretia chetvert X vv.). Khar'kov, Ukraine: Khar'kovskaya gosudarstvennaya akademiya kul'tury, 2006.

In Spanish:
        Kitroser, Félix Elias. Jazaria: el imperio olvidado por la historia. Córdoba, Argentina: Lerner, 2002.
        Ortiz, Alicia Dujovne. "El fantasma de los jázaros."La Nación (Buenos Aires, Argentina, August 14, 1999).
        Ponce del Rio, Ramiro. El imperio perdido de los jázaros. Barcelona, Spain: Ediciones Dedalo, 2007.

In Swedish:
        Wyszomirska (Werbart), Bożena Irene. "Religion som enande politisk-social länk - exemplet: det Kazariska riket." In Arkeologi och Religion: Rapport från arkeologidagarna 16-18 januari 1989, ed. Lars Larsson and Bożena Irene Wyszomirska, pp. 135-148. Lund, Sweden: University of Lund, 1989.

In Turkish:
        Atabinen, Kara Şemsi Reşit Saffet. Hazar Türkleri Avrupa devleti (VI-XII asir). Istanbul: Kaatcilik ve Matbaacilik Anonim Sirketi, 1934.
        Baştav, Şerif. "Hazar Kağanlığı Tarihi." In Tarihte Türk Devletleri, vol. 1, pp. 139-182. Ankara, Turkey: Ankara Üniversitesi, 1987.
        Golden, Peter Benjamin. "Giriş: Hazarlar." In Hazarlar ve Musevilik, ed. Osman Karatay, pp. 3-21. Çorum, Turkey: KaraM Yayınları, 2005.
        Karatay, Osman. "Hazarlar." In Doğu Avrupa Türk Tarihi, ed. Osman Karatay and Serkan Acar, pp. 335-408. Istanbul: Kitabevi Yayınları, 2013.
        Karatay, Osman. Hazarlar: Yahudi Türkler: Türk Yahudiler ve Ötekiler. Ankara, Turkey: Kripto Yayınları, 2014.
        Kuzgun, Şaban. Türklerde Yahudilik ve Doğu Avrupa Yahudilerinin menşei meselesi: Hazar ve Karay Türkleri. Edition Genisletilmis 2. baski. Ankara, Turkey: Şaban Kuzgun, 1993. Discusses Khazars, Karaites, East European Jews, and Jews in Turkey.
        Kuz'min-Yumanadi, Yakov F., and Kuleshov, Pavel V. "Hazarlar." In Türkler, vol. 2, eds. Hasan Celâl Güzel, Kemal Çiçek, and Salim Koca, pp. 464-472. Ankara, Turkey: Yeni Türkiye, 2002.
        Kuz'min-Yumanadi, Yakov F., and Kuleshov, Pavel V. "Çuvaşlar ve Etnik Oluşumları." In Türkler, vol. 2, eds. Hasan Celâl Güzel, Kemal Çiçek, and Salim Koca, pp. 491-496. Ankara, Turkey: Yeni Türkiye, 2002. About connections between the Khazars and the Chuvash.
        Özgün, Pınar. Hazarlar - Kayıp Kavim. Istanbul: Cinius Yayınları, 2013.
        Yücel, Muallâ Uydu. "Hazar Hakanlığı." In Türkler, vol. 2, eds. Hasan Celâl Güzel, Kemal Çiçek, and Salim Koca, pp. 445-463. Ankara, Turkey: Yeni Türkiye, 2002.
        Zeki Velidi Togan, Ahmed. "Hazarlar." In İslam Ansiklopedisi, vol. 5, pp. 397-408. Istanbul, 1964.

In Ukrainian:
        Klyashtornyi, Sergey Grigorievich. "Aziys'kiy aspekt rann'oyi istorii xozar." Khazarskiy al'manax 2 (Kharkiv, 2004): 47-51.

In Yiddish:
        Fainkind, Mosheh. Di Kuzerim un zeyer Yudish malkhe`s: a hekhst interesante historishe beshraybung nokh di nayeste kvelen bearbeyt. Pietrkov: Sh. Belkhatovski, 1909.
        Podolefsky, Sol. Di geshikhte fun di Kazarn un zeyer ideshe meluche in tsentrel Eyrope. New York: Rokhman, 1971.
        Stuhlbach, Dov. "A folk fun sofek-yidn, Part I." Yiddish Forverts 105:31495 (April 30, 2004): 16.
        Stuhlbach, Dov. "A folk fun sofek-yidn, Part II." Yiddish Forverts 105:31496 (May 7, 2004): 14.
        Weiss, S. Di Yidishe melukhe fun di Kuzarim. Warsaw: Grosh-bibliotek, 1932.


OTHER BIBLIOGRAPHIES

In English:


        Sheynin, Hayim Y. "Khazars." In Reader's Guide to Judaism, ed. Michael Terry, pp. 339-340. London: Routledge, 2000.
        Weinryb, Bernard Dov. "The Khazars, an annotated bibliography." Studies in Bibliography and Booklore 6 (1963): 111-129 and 11 (1976): 57-74.
        Yarmolinsky, Avrahm, et al. The Khazars; A Bibliography Compiled by the Slavonic Division. New York: The New York Public Library, 1939. Reprinted from The Bulletin of The New York Public Library 42 (September 1938): 695-710.
        Yarmolinsky, Avrahm, et al. The Khazars: A Bibliography: 1940-1958. New York: The New York Public Library, 1959. Reprinted from The Bulletin of The New York Public Library 63:5 (May 1959): 237-241.
  • Return to the table of contents


    Copyright © 1999-2017 by Kevin Alan Brook.

  • One thought on “Norman Golb Festschrift Essays

    Leave a comment

    L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *